Estimated market value (beta)
Overview
Weighted average of attribute scores for this role, position-adjusted. Standout attributes count more than weaknesses.
Attributes (grouped)
Mobility
Lost the recovery pace of his prime and can be exposed in transition at 38. (conf 0.7)
No longer a genuine sprinter, relies on positioning to compensate. (conf 0.7)
Still turns and adjusts reasonably well for his age given a strong frame. (conf 0.65)
Manages his energy across 90 minutes but is rotated in congested schedules. (conf 0.6)
Control
Reliable control under pressure built from years in possession-heavy sides. (conf 0.65)
Limited ball-carrying ambition, prefers simple progression over dribbling out. (conf 0.6)
Strong, combative frame lets him screen the ball well in tight areas. (conf 0.65)
Capable of a firm clearance or driven pass but rarely a long-range threat. (conf 0.55)
Distribution
Composed distribution from the back honed under Guardiola and Argentina. (conf 0.7)
Can switch play or find a forward with a longer diagonal when needed. (conf 0.65)
Not a crossing threat, almost never delivers from wide areas as a centre-back. (conf 0.5)
Reads passing lanes well enough to start attacks from deep positions. (conf 0.6)
Chance threat
Occasional set-piece goal threat but no real striking instinct in open play. (conf 0.55)
Rarely shoots, mostly limited to headers from corners and free kicks. (conf 0.5)
Good sense for attacking near-post runs on set pieces despite limited pace. (conf 0.55)
Not a dead-ball taker, contributes as a target rather than a striker of the ball. (conf 0.5)
Duels
Dominant in the air, a long-standing defensive and set-piece strength. (conf 0.8)
Aggressive, physical defender who wins the majority of one-on-one duels. (conf 0.75)
Defense
Engages when the situation demands but no longer presses high consistently. (conf 0.55)
Timely interceptions and blocks built on experience reading opposition attacks. (conf 0.65)
Excellent positional sense from two decades at the top level shapes his game. (conf 0.75)
Mental
Rarely rattled, a calming veteran presence in a back line under pressure. (conf 0.75)
Experienced reader of the game who makes few costly errors in judgment. (conf 0.7)
Committed defensively though covers less ground than in his City peak. (conf 0.6)
Resilience
Generally available for a player his age but managed carefully with rotation. (conf 0.55)
Outlook
Late-career veteran with minimal remaining upward trajectory left. (conf 0.7)
World Cup winner and Manchester City stalwart, a recognized Argentine icon. (conf 0.85)
Quick navigation
No roster-based suggestions yet.
Compare Nicolás Hernán Gonzalo Otamendi with…
Scouting Report & Player Insights
Nicolás Otamendi is a veteran Argentine centre-back now marshalling Benfica's defence, prized for his aerial dominance, physical duels and no-nonsense positioning built over a long career including six-plus seasons at Manchester City. Pace has faded with age, and he is no threat with the ball at his feet, but his reading of the game, composure and set-piece presence remain assets. He captains Argentina's back line and was a key figure in their 2022 World Cup triumph. At Benfica he anchors a defense relying on his experience and leadership as much as his athleticism.
Won the 2022 World Cup with Argentina.
Spent five seasons at Manchester City between 2015 and 2020, winning two Premier League titles.
Long-serving Argentina international and regular starter at centre-back for the national team.
Joined Benfica after leaving Manchester City.